HOME Opinion

 

 

Home  

 

 

Pakistan's Trojan Horse
By Irshad Salim

 

No one party has won a simple majority of the 272 parliamentary seats in Pakistan's new national assembly.. The 'King's party- PML(Q) bagged 76 seats which relate to only 28 percent of the total. In fact if one adds up the number of seats bagged by the anti-Musharraf forces, it equals to more than 43 percent, notwithstanding the independents who enjoy 22 seats in the new parliament.

One combination would have been PPP-PML(N)-MMA-MQM  coalition (144 seats > 137 required). But such a coalition  between Benazir-Nawaz Sharif-Qazi Hussain Ahmed and Altaf Hussain's parties would not only be 'unholy', based on each party's conflicting manifesto, but totally  unacceptable to Musharraf at the outset.

From Musharraf's standpoint, such a coalition would guarantee continued opposition to his policies present and future and an agenda for disaster on provincial levels. MMA already control NWFP and Baluchistan provinces with its pro-Taliban policies. MQM controls urban Sindh and their existence depends on opposing the 'power to be'. Lastly, PPP and personally Benazir hates his guts. As far as Nawaz Sharif is concerned, he is already committed to Musharraf's ouster ever since he was sent away to Saudi Arabia on a negotiated 10 year exile!

No wonder then that the military junta jumped on the idea of stitching a coalition between two opposing forces: PML(Q) which is 'King's party' and PPPP which is a subsidiary of Musharraf's main opposition party: PPP.

Once it was clear that the six religious parties alliance, MMA, has taken control of Pakistan's two northern provinces, NWFP and Baluchistan, it was essential to counter the emerging political scenario with a stronger moderate force on the national level. Thus, military's and ISI's swift somersault in favor of bringing PML(Q) and PPPP on talking terms and assisting them  in forming a  coalition government.

Such a move would insure a strong effective opposition to "rightist forces" within and outside the parliament thereby providing the neccessary continuance of Musharraf's policy of aligning Pakistan with the West.

Makhdoom Fahim, second in command of PPP did hold secret talks with the 'powers to be' and rushed to London to extract Benazir's blessings on his agreement with Musharraf and the ISI on the proposed 'coalition'.

I keep separating Musharraf from ISI. They are actually separate but they appear to be presently united due to expediencies and one common present cause: to satisfy West's demand to help them weed out Islamic extremism!

The emergence of Mutahidda Majlis-e-Amal (MMA), an Islamic coalition of six fiery anti-Western religious parties, has changed the dynamics of the country's politics for ever and now MMA holds the balance of power in every bit of the  classical sense.

International observers from the European Union have said that Pakistan's general election was seriously flawed by official interference in favour of parties supporting President Pervez Musharraf. Acutally it was seriously flawed because the Islamic parties managed to get a wider stage to perform now. Remember Algeria?

But present and future trends speak otherwise. Personally, I do not agree with EU observer's observations, because the 'end must justify the means'. The net result is that Musharraf's team having miscalculated the emergence of an anti-Musharraf-albeit-anti-western-forces' on the national level, have ended up to possible witness  a 'Trojan horse!

Three years of military rule by General Musharraf have left the country divided. But it it understandable!

Making a U-turn is not easy specially if it is not backed by popular sentiments. Making a U-turn is not easy if it cannot be articulated to the man on the street. The man on the street has a romance  with the past and an obsession for 'Islamic revival' no matter how illogical it may sound to him.

Even if a PML(Q) and PPPP coalition government  is established at the center with the Army's blessings, the Islamic parties , including but not limited to MQM from sindh will continue to pursue thieir own agendas which presently stand in direct opposition to Musharraf's policy of carrying forward Pakistan to the international stage of 'moderate countries'.

While MMA's existence is primarily based on opposing 'western influences' in Pakistan and establishment of an Ummah, MQM's existence is based on opposing the status quo at the center and its pursuit for provincial autonnomy. Both these agendas end up on the backburner, much to their discomfort, because of Musharraf and the Army's pre-occupation with the West's agendas.

Given MMA component parties' history and MQM's history at opposing forces in the center, there is no doubt that both these parties will eventually find themselves on same side of the fence. United, both these parties will be a force to reckon with.

Whoever is in power, the coalition government and/or the National Security Council (I mean Musharraf), will find it difficult not to 'listen' to MMA's and MQM's demands.

According to news reports, leaders of the PML-QA and the PPPP are locked in secret talks to hammer out a post-election deal on the formation of a coalition government.

The PPP would cooperate fully with the PML-QA to work for national reconciliation, PPP leader Makhdoon Amin Fahim told a press conference after returning from London. The two parties would discuss the possibility of forming a coalition central government, he announced.

No wonder then, that the establishment has strongly encouraged two opposing parties viz: PML(Q) and PPPP to get together to form a government at the center ASAP lest other parties grap the opportunity and proceed to form a right-wing coalition of their own.

Traditionally, the religious parties have had trouble forming an alliance with an ethnic party like MQM, but there is always room for creativity given MQM's hold over urban Karachi which has always been a bastion of street power.

General Musharraf, who is West's 'ally against terror' for another five years, is therefore clearly keen to get an assembly with which he can work.  The election results have produced as many  'independent variables' as they have produced 'dependable variables'.

An alliance between PML(Q) and PPPP may only temporarily glue the two variables to provide the 'powers to be' the opportunity to fullfill their new agenda. But the nation of Pakistan deserve a better deal than accomodating a quick-fix with no guarantee of success and sustained performance!

 



News stories:
Europe isn't marching to U.S. drum
Iran's Crown Prince plots insurrection
US company, not Powell helped stop Indo-Pak war

Home

Top

Next

Questions? email us
Copyright © 1999-2002 DesPardes Inc. All Rights Reserved
Site developed & maintained by  Mamosa Solutions Inc., NJ, USA