The Angels of the
Ghetto
 NOV
3: Miss972, as she called herself on an Internet blog, was overcome
with grief."I didn't know you, but it hurts so much to lose
someone and I will never be able to forget you," she wrote, posting
her heartache to one of the dozens of French Internet blogs newly
dedicated to two teenaged boys who have come to be known as "the
angels of the ghetto."
The two boys Traore Bouna, 15, and Zyed Benna, 17 were electrocuted in a gruesome accident in Clichy-sous-Bois, one of the grim, densely populated suburban slums
ringing Paris. They apparently thought police were chasing them,
although the police say they were not involved. A third teenager
with them was seriously injured.
The deaths, a week ago today, have sparked a week of rioting that
has spread to at least 20 towns, leaving a trail of tear-gas
grenades, hundreds of burned cars and fire-blackened buildings in
the worst urban violence France has seen for years.
The dead teenagers have been lionized as martyrs to police
heavy-handedness, to racism and to decades of official neglect of
the country's underclass of African and Arab immigrants.
Despite calls for calm by President Jacques Chirac and religious
leaders, and a cordial meeting between Prime Minister Dominique de
Villepin and the parents of the teenagers, the disturbances
continued for an eighth consecutive night.
Youths went on the rampage in ten areas in poor suburbs ringing
the French capital to the north and the east, setting alight about
315 cars, two buses and dumpsters, as well as causing damage to at
least one school, a shopping centre, a police post, a Renault car dealership and a local gymnasium.
Elsewhere a France 2 TV crew were forced by hooded youths to abandon
their car, which was then set ablaze by 40 rioters, reports AFP.
"Emotions must quiet down," Mr. Chirac told government ministers
yesterday, a government spokesman reported. Hundreds of police were
deployed to control the disturbances, with some units diverted from
a soccer match.
The fiery images from the suburbs recalled earlier tragedies that
roiled the immigrant communities, particularly the string of fires
in dilapidated apartment buildings in Paris in August and September.
The fires killed 24 people, all of them immigrants crammed into
illegal housing who had been promised decent lodging for years.
"People are joining together to say we've had enough," a
22-year-old named Eric told Associated Press in Clichy-sous-Bois,
heavily populated by first-and second-generation North African and
Muslim immigrants.
Eric was born in France to Moroccan parents.
"We live in ghettos," he added refusing to give his surname.
"Everyone lives in fear."
The unrest has highlighted the division between France’s big cities
and their poor suburbs. Frustrations have been simmering in housing
projects that dominate the area, which is marked by high
unemployment, crime and poverty.
France's PM, Mr. de Villepin, canceling his planned departure for Canada, said "There is no miracle solution to the situation
faced by these neighborhoods."
The
violence has also cast doubt on the success of France’s model of
seeking to integrate its large immigrant community – its Muslim
population, at an estimated five million, is Western Europe’s
largest – by playing down differences between ethnic groups. But
rather than be embraced as full and equal citizens, immigrants and
their French-born children often complain of police harassment and
of being refused jobs, housing and opportunities.
Opposition groups accused the government of letting the situation
spiral out of control, either by failing to act quickly enough or
letting in too many immigrants over the years.
Public officials have reacted with a mix of political
name-calling and renewed promises to improve living conditions for
France's poor. While state agencies hesitated, leaving the police to
restore order with tear gas and raids, independent Muslim leaders
from local mosques stepped in to organize peaceful demonstrations
and to dispatch mediators into neighborhoods to calm young people.
“We see that the situation in certain neighborhoods is not getting
better at all, but degenerating,” Socialist Party President
Jean-Marc Ayrault told LCI television, who said Chirac’s
conservatives “did not know how to take control.”
Right-wing French MP Philippe de Villiers, who has said he wants to
“stop the Islamisation of France,” told RTL radio that the problem
stemmed from the “failure of a policy of massive and uncontrolled
immigration.”
Minister of Social Cohesion Jean-Louis Borloo said the government
had to react “firmly” but added that France must also acknowledge
its failure to have dealt with anger simmering in poor suburbs for
decades.
“We cannot hide the truth: that for 30 years we have not done
enough,” he told France-2 television.
The grievances have been further fuelled by France's Interior
Minister Sarkozy’s hard-line law-and-order policies, who has all but
declared his candidacy for president in the 2007 elections.
Faced with smaller-scale outbreaks of violence in slum areas
during the past few months, he railed against "riff-raff" and
pledged "zero tolerance" for delinquents.
Just one week before the riots exploded, he promised a “war without
mercy” on violence and petty crime in the suburbs.
Residents and opposition politicians have accused Sarkozy of fanning
tensions with his tough police tactics and talk — including calling
troublemakers "scum."
"Sarkozy's language has added oil to the fire. He should really
weigh his words," said Kaci, whose daughter lost her gym. "I'm proud
to live in France, but this France disappoints me."
Arab-descent French immigrant, Mouloud, 70, said he was deeply
shocked by the interior minister’s comments last month, when he
vowed to “clean up” the “rabble” in the suburbs, using a
water-cannon.
Sarkozy has cancelled his trip next week to Pakistan and Afghanistan. PM Villepin
said he was counting on Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy to deal
with the situation — to “take the necessary measures.”
Azouz Begag, the feisty Minister for Equal Opportunities and a
native of the suburban housing projects, has advocated a different
approach, blaming the outbreak of violence on a persistent sense of
disenfranchisement in the slums that is aggravated by the failure of
the state to include minorities in the security forces.
He has called for a full public debate on France's policies for
assimilating immigrants and overcoming discrimination. "After all,"
he said recently, "it's not uninteresting to see that two ministers
do not see the same France."
(Agencies) |